CctRepresentation/WorkSession 2004 06 18 CCT

CCT Representation Project - CCTONT Work Session - June 18, 2004    (T9)

Conference Call Details    (TA)

• Subject: [CCT-Rep] CCTONT Work Session Fri 2004-06-18    (TB)
• Agenda:    (TC)
  • mainly to review and discuss CCTONT v0.2    (TD)
  • Draft agenda - see: http://ontolog.cim3.net/forum/cctont-imp/2004-06/msg00011.html#nid05 (item BB-1: 1 thru 4)    (TE)
  • please post any suggested agenda items to the call wiki page and upload any material to be shared to the list, to the wiki or by WebDAV upload to the file workspace described below prior to the meeting.    (TF)
  • VNC session will be started 5 minutes before the call at: http://vnc4.cim3.net:5800/    (TG)
    • view-only password: "cctont"    (TH)
    • view-and-control pw: "cctont-imp"    (TI)
  • To contribute, and during the call, please access the wiki page at: http://ontolog.cim3.net/cgi-bin/wiki.pl?CctRepresentation/WorkSession_2004_06_18_CCT    (TJ)
• Date: Friday, June 18, 2004    (TK)
• Start Time: 10:30 AM Pacific Standard Time    (TL)
• End Time: 11:55 AM Pacific Standard Time    (TM)
• Dial-in Number: 1-702-851-3330 (Las Vegas, Nevada)    (TN)
• Participant Access Code: "0686564#"    (TO)

Attendees    (TP)

• Attended:    (TQ)
  • AdamPease    (TR)
  • GarretMinakawa    (TS)
  • PeterYim    (TT)

• Expecting:    (TU)
  • AlanStitzer    (TV)

• Invited:    (TW)
  • NenadIvezic    (TX)
  • TimMcGrath    (TY)
  • SueProbert    (TZ)

Communications - Protocol - Logistics    (U0)

• [CCT-Rep] project homepage on this wiki: CctRepresentation    (U1)

• Communications / Discussion (via email):    (U2)
  • post to: mailto:cctont-imp@ontolog.cim3.net (subscribers only)    (U3)
  • discussion archives: http://ontolog.cim3.net/forum/cctont-imp/ (open to the public)    (U4)

• File workspace:    (U5)
  • Project work: http://ontolog.cim3.net/file/work/CCT-Representation/    (U6)
  • Work-in-progress: http://ontolog.cim3.net/file/work/CCT-Representation/wip/    (U7)

• Feedback, Comments, Suggestions for the CCT-Representaion project work: /CctRep_Feedback    (U8)
  • this is for collecting feedback from the team, the ontolog community, the e-business standards development community, and the public at large to the CCT-Ontology development team (i.e. for incoming feedback, from ontolog's perspective) to collaboratively improve on the quality and relevance of this work.    (U9)

• Draft Feedback and Recommendations for other eBusiness Standards Working Groups: /CctRep_Recommendation    (UA)
  • this is in preparation for the compilation of position paper(s) that the CCT-Ontology working team and the Ontolog community can present to the various e-business standards development bodies (i.e. for outgoinging feedback, from ontolog's perspective) that will include (but not limited to) learnings and recommendations as a result of this work.    (UB)

Agenda & Proceedings    (UC)

• 0. Peter: workspace and infrastructure detailed above has been set up to augment this work.    (UD)

• 1. Adam: walk-through of the CCTONT v0-2f artifact.    (UE)

•    (UF)
  • need to remove notes in the spreadsheet and just state the mappings    (UG)

• 2. All: Q & A    (UH)

•    (UI)
  • Garret: IPR issues    (UJ)
    • Peter: please refer to http://ontolog.cim3.net/cgi-bin/wiki.pl#nid036    (UK)
      • the version of SUMO we are extending from is Public Domain (with IPR being attributed to IEEE)    (UL)
      • Adam's SIGMA-kee is under GPL    (UM)
      • unless otherwise specified, IPR to our work product defaults to the OASIS IPR policy terms, with IPR being held by the individual contributors.    (UN)
  • Peter: Hhow is the CCTONT delivered. Will the CCTONT be monolithic, and have all (or all the necessary) SUMO and MILO, plus whatever else already out there that is needed (like the QoS_Ontology, in our case)?    (UO)
    • Adam: we can decide on that. However, on the SIGMA-kee, you can load the individual ontologies separately, and SIGMA will present them seamlessly (with a remarking telling you where the axioms come from).    (UP)

• 3. Discussion: how should this be presented to a typical eBusiness Standards body to have it make sense to the audience and make the desired impact.    (UQ)

•    (US)
  • for a starter, we can present an alternative specification as an alternative to the natural language definition for each and every CCT term specified, stated in KIF (and based on First Order Logic), which we will present as being a more rigorous definition to the said term.    (UT)
  • would be nice if we could hyperlink the CCT vocabulary and present that on a browser through the SIGMA-kee    (UU)
  • we'll essentially be presenting what equivalent to cells [A6..G61] of the v0-2f worksheet, but updated with SUMO references against each CCT type and component.    (UV)

• 4. Follow-up, next steps and workplan update.    (UW)
  • will merge the spreadsheet entries and map all CCT Supplementary Components to SUMO as well.    (UX)
  • Adam will work on the linking of the spreadsheet to SIGMA-kee for presentation.    (UY)
  • we continue to work against the short-term plan agreed to on our 2004.06.15 work session, and will aim at opening up this segment of the work to review and comments from the ontolog community early next week.    (UZ)
  • by the way, Garret has cancelled his trip to Waldorf, Germany, and will therefore have more time to spend on this project. He's deffering his comments to later next week.    (V0)

Action Items [ --by / due ]    (V1)

• Adam will work on merging the spreadsheet and hyperlinking that for SIGMA browser presentation. This will be CCTONT v0.3 [--AdamPease / 2004.06.19]    (V2)
• All: continue discussion over the [cctont-imp] amiling list, and post insights to /CctRep_Feedback & /CctRep_Recommendation as appropriate.    (V3)

• call adjourned 11:43am PDT    (V4)
  • the sub-team will continue the exchange over the [cctont-imp] list.    (V5)
  • if another call is need, we'll initiate it from the mailing list.    (V6)

 --
 notes captured by ppy / 2004.06.18_12:16_PDT    (V7)