OntologySummit2007: OntologySummit2007_Survey individual responses (ZDU)
OntologySummit2007_Survey/Response input from CharlesTurnitsa (ZDV)
Please make sure you refer to the OntologySummit2007 & OntologySummit2007_Survey pages for the full context of the input. T (ZDW)
Question 1 Respondant Info (ZDX)
Name: Charles Turnitsa (ZFZ)
Question 2 Affiliated - I am affiliated with the following constituencies/communities (please check all that apply) (ZDZ)
[X] Formal ontology communities [ ] Semantic Web communities [ ] Linguistic communities [ ] Concept Map community [ ] Topic Map community [ ] SEARCH communities [ ] Web 2.0 communities [ ] Thesauri community [ ] Taxonomy communities [ ] Metadata communities [ ] XML communities [X] Applications Development, Software Engineering and Information Model communities [X] System Architecture communities [ ] Biomedical communities [X] Standards Development communities [ ] Other (please specify): (Not Answered) (ZE0)
Question 2a Representing - I represent the perspective of the following constituency/community (please pick one; if you want to provide input from more than one perspective, please return a separate form): (ZE1)
[X] 1. Formal ontology communities [ ] 2. Semantic Web communities [ ] 3. Linguistic communities [ ] 4. Concept Map community [ ] 5. Topic Map community [ ] 6. SEARCH communities [ ] 7. Web 2.0 communities [ ] 8. Thesauri community [ ] 9. Taxonomy communities [ ] 10. Metadata communities [ ] 11. XML communities [ ] 12. Applications Development, Software Engineering and Information Model communities [ ] 13. System Architecture communities [ ] 14. Biomedical communities [ ] 15. Standards Development communities [ ] 16. Other (please specify): (Not Answered) (ZE2)
Question 2b Specific Community (ZE3)
or sub-community I am affiliated with: modeling and simulation (ZE4)
Question 2c Expertise Self Assessment - With respect to the perspective you are representing and providing input from, I am a/an: (ZE5)
[ ] 1. informed layman [ ] 2. practitioner [ ] 3. expert [X] 4. other (please specify): expert in training (ZE6)
Question 3a Ontology Value (ZE7)
"Representing meaning for the purposes of interoperability between complex systems." (ZE8)
Question 3b Ontology Issues (ZE9)
"Accomodating a representation of meaning for synthetic environment systems that are representing the same real-world referent, but from a different perspective or perhaps a different focus." (ZEA)
Question 3c Ontology Problems (ZEB)
"quantifying the meaning of terms, in order to identify and evaluate synonyms and homonyms between systems" (ZEC)
Question 3d Corresponding Solutions (ZED)
"currently researching and evaluating an approach relying on primitives of meaning in order to address the problem of specific representation and quantification of meaning" (ZEE)
Question 4a Glossary - Ontology-related 'vocabulary' and representative 'artifact' from your constituency or community: (ZEF)
Term: ontology Gloss: "...an artifact that represents some portion of the world in a fashion that can be processed by a machine." - Chris Welty Reference (citation/url): Welty, C.; Ontology Research, AI Magazine, 24(3), Fall 2003, American Association for Artificial Intelligence Artifact (name/version): (Not Answered) - Artifact Ref. (url): (Not Answered) (ZEG)
Question 4a1 Called An Ontology - On a scale of 1 to 5, (where 1 means totally unlikely and 5 means almost always), would the above term or artifact be referred to as an "ontology" in your community? (ZEH)
[ ] 1. 1 - totally unlikely [ ] 2. 2 - rarely [ ] 3. 3 - sometimes [X] 4. 4 - quite often [ ] 5. 5 - almost always (ZEI)
Question 4a2 Additional Remarks - (ZEJ)
"(Not Answered)" (ZEK)
Question 4b Glossary - Ontology-related 'vocabulary' and representative 'artifact' from your constituency or community: (ZEL)
Term: (Not Answered) Gloss: (Not Answered) Reference (citation/url): (Not Answered) Artifact (name/version): Joint Warfare Simulation Object Library - Artifact Ref. (url): Conwell, C.L. Joint Warfare Simulation Object Library, U.S. Navy Research and Development Technical Document TD2808, Washington, DC, June 1995 (ZEM)
Question 4b1 Called An Ontology - On a scale of 1 to 5, (where 1 means totally unlikely and 5 means almost always), would the above term or artifact be referred to as an "ontology" in your community? (ZEN)
[ ] 1. 1 - totally unlikely [ ] 2. 2 - rarely [X] 3. 3 - sometimes [ ] 4. 4 - quite often [ ] 5. 5 - almost always (ZEO)
Question 4b2 Additional Remarks - (ZEP)
"Provides a strong taxonomical structure (based on a heirarchy divided up into broad conceptual areas of agent, physical, and event entities). Lacks a method for formally capturing "meaning" of entities, and is very limited in scope in that it only addresses elements of specific interest to the domain of Joint Warfare simulation, and only from a U.S.-centric perspective. Atomic concepts required for such a simulation are missing, as are other perspectives relative to the domain." (ZEQ)
Question 4c Glossary - Ontology-related 'vocabulary' and representative 'artifact' from your constituency or community: (ZER)
Term: Primitives of meaning Gloss: Universal (for the domain and its community) idea that provides meaning for one aspect of an entity. Reference (citation/url): Tolk, A., Turnitsa, C., Diallo, S.; "IMPLIED ONTOLOGICAL REPRESENTATION WITHIN THE LEVELS OF CONCEPTUAL INTEROPERABILITY MODEL", submitted to IDT for publication, awaiting review Artifact (name/version): (Not Answered) - Artifact Ref. (url): (Not Answered) (ZES)
Question 4c1 Called An Ontology - On a scale of 1 to 5, (where 1 means totally unlikely and 5 means almost always), would the above term or artifact be referred to as an "ontology" in your community? (ZET)
[ ] 1. 1 - totally unlikely [X] 2. 2 - rarely [ ] 3. 3 - sometimes [ ] 4. 4 - quite often [ ] 5. 5 - almost always (ZEU)
Question 4c2 Additional Remarks - (ZEV)
"A theory that may provide the means for identifying and quantifying meaning." (ZEW)
Question 4d Glossary - Ontology-related 'vocabulary' and representative 'artifact' from your constituency or community: (ZEX)
Term: (Not Answered) Gloss: (Not Answered) Reference (citation/url): (Not Answered) Artifact (name/version): (Not Answered) - Artifact Ref. (url): (Not Answered) (ZEY)
Question 4d1 Called An Ontology - On a scale of 1 to 5, (where 1 means totally unlikely and 5 means almost always), would the above term or artifact be referred to as an "ontology" in your community? (ZEZ)
[ ] 1. 1 - totally unlikely [ ] 2. 2 - rarely [ ] 3. 3 - sometimes [ ] 4. 4 - quite often [ ] 5. 5 - almost always (ZF0)
Question 4d2 Additional Remarks - (ZF1)
"(Not Answered)" (ZF2)
Question 4e Glossary - Ontology-related 'vocabulary' and representative 'artifact' from your constituency or community: (ZF3)
Term: (Not Answered) Gloss: (Not Answered) Reference (citation/url): (Not Answered) Artifact (name/version): (Not Answered) - Artifact Ref. (url): (Not Answered) (ZF4)
Question 4e1 Called An Ontology - On a scale of 1 to 5, (where 1 means totally unlikely and 5 means almost always), would the above term or artifact be referred to as an "ontology" in your community? (ZF5)
[ ] 1. 1 - totally unlikely [ ] 2. 2 - rarely [ ] 3. 3 - sometimes [ ] 4. 4 - quite often [ ] 5. 5 - almost always (ZF6)
Question 4e2 Additional Remarks - (ZF7)
"(Not Answered)" (ZF8)
Question 4f Glossary - Ontology-related 'vocabulary' and representative 'artifact' from your constituency or community: (ZF9)
Term: (Not Answered) Gloss: (Not Answered) Reference (citation/url): (Not Answered) Artifact (name/version): (Not Answered) - Artifact Ref. (url): (Not Answered) (ZFA)
Question 4f1 Called An Ontology - On a scale of 1 to 5, (where 1 means totally unlikely and 5 means almost always), would the above term or artifact be referred to as an "ontology" in your community? (ZFB)
[ ] 1. 1 - totally unlikely [ ] 2. 2 - rarely [ ] 3. 3 - sometimes [ ] 4. 4 - quite often [ ] 5. 5 - almost always (ZFC)
Question 4f2 Additional Remarks - (ZFD)
"(Not Answered)" (ZFE)
Question 4g Glossary - Ontology-related 'vocabulary' and representative 'artifact' from your constituency or community: (ZFF)
Term: (Not Answered) Gloss (definition): (Not Answered) Reference (citation/url): (Not Answered) Artifact (name/version): (Not Answered) - Artifact Ref. (url): (Not Answered) (ZFG)
Question 4g1 Called An Ontology - On a scale of 1 to 5, (where 1 means totally unlikely and 5 means almost always), would the above term or artifact be referred to as an "ontology" in your community? (ZFH)
[ ] 1. 1 - totally unlikely [ ] 2. 2 - rarely [ ] 3. 3 - sometimes [ ] 4. 4 - quite often [ ] 5. 5 - almost always (ZFI)
Question 4g2 Additional Remarks - (ZFJ)
"(Not Answered)" (ZFK)
Question 4h Glossary - Ontology-related 'vocabulary' and representative 'artifact' from your constituency or community: (ZFL)
Term: (Not Answered) Gloss: (Not Answered) Reference (citation/url): (Not Answered) Artifact (name/version): (Not Answered) - Artifact Ref. (url): (Not Answered) (ZFM)
Question 4h1 Called An Ontology - On a scale of 1 to 5, (where 1 means totally unlikely and 5 means almost always), would the above term or artifact be referred to as an "ontology" in your community? (ZFN)
[ ] 1. 1 - totally unlikely [ ] 2. 2 - rarely [ ] 3. 3 - sometimes [ ] 4. 4 - quite often [ ] 5. 5 - almost always (ZFO)
Question 4h2 Additional Remarks - (ZFP)
"(Not Answered)" (ZFQ)
Question 5 Confirm Participation - where, (ZFR)
a 'convener' is a participant who provides substantive contribution to the OntologySummit2007 initiative (through the online discourse, this survey, and other events leading to or during the workshops and the written communique process), and (ZFS)
a 'co-sponsor' is an organization who is providing technical or funding support (e.g. supporting member(s) of its technical staff to participate as a 'convener'), and/or endorsing the objective of this OntologySummit2007, (ZFT)
[ ] I agree that my name can be listed as a 'convener' of OntologySummit2007 [ ] I will consider endorsing the OntologySummit2007 communique. Please send it to me for review when it is ready. I will confirm my endorsement after the review. [ ] I confirm that you may list my organization as a 'co-sponsor' for OntologySummit2007 (details below). (ZFU)
Organization Name: Virginia Modeling Analysis and Simulation Center Link (url) to Logo:(ZFW)
-- This page is maintained by: PeterYim Please forward any modification and update, along with the change justification) to him for posting. T (ZFX)
Individual's input pages should only be changed by by the above designated maintainer, or the individual himself/herself. Please append any (non-typo) modification at the bottom of the each page, leaving the original survey input intact. T (ZFY)