Difference (from prior revision)

Changed: 69c69

* while MichelleRaymond's [http://ontolog.cim3.net/cgi-bin/wiki.pl?OntologySummit2008/Idea#nid18CC proposed list of topics] is very comprehensive, I suspect that the 11 weeks we have (between the Feb-7 launch and the Apr-28 face-to-face workshop) may not allow us to fully tackle them thoroughly. I suggest we decide what we want to drop out as deliverable(s) - vis-a-vis what we want to see in a joint communique from the summit conveners - and then work backwards on identifying the appropriate sub-teams to tackle the key facets that need to be covered to allow the communique to be meaningful and representative of the expertise and effort that this community has put into it. (--comment from PeterYim / 2008.01.31) {nid 18MS}
* while MichelleRaymond's [http://ontolog.cim3.net/cgi-bin/wiki.pl?OntologySummit2008/Idea#nid18CC proposed list of topics] is very comprehensive, I suspect that the 11 weeks we have (between the Feb-7 launch and the Apr-28 face-to-face workshop) may not allow us to fully tackle them thoroughly. I suggest we decide what we want to drop out as deliverable(s) - vis-a-vis what we want to see in a joint communiqué from the summit conveners - and then work backwards on identifying the appropriate sub-teams to tackle the key facets that need to be covered to allow the communiqué to be meaningful and representative of the expertise and effort that this community has put into it. (--comment from PeterYim / 2008.01.31) {nid 18MS}

Added: 103a104,110

The "deliverable" from this meeting is a set of main topics that support the theme of
the OntologySummit2008 and possible champions for each of the main topics. {nid 18VI}

The champions for each main topic can facilitate keeping discussion threads active in that area. They also play the lead role in keeping the associated Synopsis pages updated for the main topic and its discussion threads. {nid 18VJ}

Synopsis pages contain an information overview of the topic threads and external links related to the topics. This allows user's to see the main points of a discussion and drill into the discussion threads or to reference resources cited here from the discussion threads. {nid 18VK}

Added: 105a113,124

In support of this meeting's [http://ontolog.cim3.net/cgi-bin/wiki.pl?ConferenceCall_2008_02_01#nid18N0 purpose]: {nid 18VL}

I. Review topics given the following criteria: {nid 18VM}

:1) The topic has been expressed to be of interest (.i.e. somebody cares about this topic enough to participate in its discussion and perhaps enough to be the champion of a synopsis page covering the topic.) {nid 18VN}

:2) The topic is important in moving us toward an open ontology repository. {nid 18VO}

II. Group topics into 3 to 5 main subject areas. {nid 18VP}

III. Rally champions for the main subject areas. {nid 18VQ}

Added: 107a127,151

* What's out there now? {nid 18VR}
** (BarrySmith) Any OWL or DAML listing ontologies that meet some minimal standard? {nid 18VT}
** (PatHayes) Look at the need for verification of ontologies. [We need a] clear notion of what ontology is. {nid 18VV}
** (FrankOlken) [Look at] current practices and approaches in Ontology Repositories and Registries. - Standards work. - Current implementation. {nid 18VX}
** (SteveRay) Standards, issues, lessons learned. {nid 18VZ}
** (FrankOlken) All repositories and standards are not ontologies {nid 18WF}

* Topics for Focus {nid 18W0}
** Stemming from the [http://ontolog.cim3.net/cgi-bin/wiki.pl?ConferenceCall_2008_02_01#nid18VR What's out there now?] discussion {nid 18WE}
*** (PeterYim) '''"State of the Art"''' as a [Main Topic] {nid 18WC}
*** '''FrankOlken agreed to champion "State of the Art".''' {nid 18WD}
** (PeterYim) Architecture and implementation out of picture. Defer Architecture and Applications to the Open Ontology Repository (OOR) group. {nid 18W2}
** (PeterYim) Pick [focus] topics by who will champion the topic. {nid 18W4}
** (PeterYim) [Consider the] Communiqué. {nid 18W6}
*** (SteveRay) [To produce the Communiqué,] document the consensus and findings and sign up to agree on map or harmonize like last year’s upper ontologies. {nid 18W9}
** () What is the relationship between Ontologies in a repository? {nid 18WB}

* Architecture {nid 18WG}
** Let's see what the community provides in discussion interest. {nid 18WH}

* Communiqué {nid 18WI}
** Organizing Committee {nid 18WJ}

* {nid 18WK}

Changed: 118c162

:2. Initalize Topic Area Synopsis pages (PeterYim will provide pages with initial
:2. Initialize Topic Area Synopsis pages (PeterYim will provide pages with initial

Added: 122a167,171

* Feb 7, 2008 Ontolog Forum Thursday meeting. {nid 18WL}
** Present 5 pages and explain that champions will post and introduce and capture discussions etc and traffic in discussion groups on the Synopsis Pages. Peter to template the pages. {nid 18WM}
** 5 Topic areas champions - Steve will lead and call on Champions. {nid 18WN}
** To separate main threads use hyphenated words in email subjects. Michelle to choose words. example - Subject:[state-of-art]DAML Ontology list {nid 18WO}

Changed: 131c180

8) Audio archive of the session: click '''[http://ontolog.cim3.net/file/work/OntologySummit2008/2008-02-01_ContentPlanning/OntologySummit2008-content-planning-meeting_AudioRecording-143212_20080201.mp3 here]''' (mp3) [ 1 Hr. 52 min. / 12.8 MB ] {nid 18OQ}
8) Audio archive of the session: click '''[http://ontolog.cim3.net/file/work/OntologySummit2008/2008-02-01_ContentPlanning/OntologySummit2008-content-planning-meeting_AudioRecording-143212_20080201.mp3 here]''' (mp3) [ 1 Hr. 52 min. / 12.8 MB ] {nid 18OQ} {nid 18WP}